"Now dont get me wrong. this (4/15) is not a good show, trey’s condition at this time was awful and very sad to see. BUT. this vegas run gets too much sh*t from the fans. first night was not good, but the other 2 nights have great dark, funky sweet jams. it might sound bad to say (jaded vets hate it when i say this), but people need to look at this run from a musical/musicians standpoint and say “hmm that was very sloppy but a fun dark riff!” you know who else was sloppy on stage? led zeppelin. and look at them. just my 2 cents. hate me all you want. "

"I think this is the worst Phish show ever My personal attended shows are 11-29-2003 Spectrum and MPP 8-15-2009 but all of these 3 are worse even if you take their best moments and combine them into 1 show of standouts the show is still worse than Coventry N1 of course but even N2 and perhaps a few others are in the running in the June 2004 tour (not 6-19 the ONLY amazing show in 2004) or the few shows in August (I am partial and defend the final 2 set show at Camden 8-12 I actually think Trey was relaxed that one last time and took a lot of OXY and a ten shots of tequila and said f it and made a great show strangely enough but still only 3.9 level great These 3 Vegas shows were the only ones ever I would give a 1 star or less rating to....Not only was Trey loaded and not present or even in the same universe ....he had a migraine the flu or cold at least and a sore throat for sure and his obsession w Jay-Z and shitty rap in 2004 cannot be understated Rap sounds amazing drunk or high on opiates but that does not make it good rap Only 2Pac NAS's Illmatic and The Chronic both the original and 2001 are epic rap albums The Blueprint 1 and 3 are good albums but for trey to suck Beyonce's hubby in Brooklyn N2 in June 8 and here again in Vegas is so pathetic and sad I love you Trey but stick to what you can play SOBER FUNK and SOUL and R and B like Stevie Wonder (Songs in the Key of Life is one of the best albums ever made) or Soul like (Dont You Wanna Go Johnny B Goode My Soul Alaska On Your Way Down Jesus Just Left Chicago) or bluegrass like If I Could (Alison Krauss bluegrass and Fiona Apple jazz and JUST blues my heroes) FEFU Uncle Pen (the origin OG) Ginseng Sullivan Old Home Place Scent of a Mule Nellie Cane Poor Heart My Sweet One Let's Go (2016 bring it back Mike.... it is POP royalty(Evolve is SO NOT POP royalty but what Darwin burped and vomited up when making up a false religion like Jesus Leaving Chicago is blues royalty) Beauty of My Dreams Middle of the Road Rocky Top Im Blue and Im Lonesome Corrina If You Need a Fool Paul and Silas Daniel Saw the Stone Dont You Wanna Go? (1995 more gospel and blues but also sorta bluegrass bar tune)"

"I have been listening through the entire LivePhish discography chronologically and this is hands down the sloppiest Phish show I have ever heard… "

"Musically I don't think this show is nearly as bad people complain about. yeah there is a mistake made during Down with Disease but they realized it and members start laughing realizing they messed up. this show has experimental playing. yes there are some mistakes but really a band that relies heavily on improv can't be immune to make a few mistakes. But Trey's voice is pretty hoarse throughout. so much so he realizes it during Timber and just stops trying in midsong and the band just takes off on a jam in midsong for awhile just give him a break to finish the song vocally. but that's this show in a nutshell: hoarse vocals and experimental jamming."

"Phunkphanatic 81 your the biggest loser! Way to write off an entire era of the band cuz you don't like one show. And worst on the site? Nope. Sorry. "